马上注册登录，享用更多感控资源，助你轻松入门。
您需要 登录 才可以下载或查看，没有账号？注册
|
×
感谢丁香园TESIR战友的素材提供。
首先提供英文原版：
The Journal is:
Journal of Hematology & Oncology
Editor-in-Chief: Delong Liu, New York Medical College
http://www.jhoonline.org/
Delong Liu, MD, PhD -
http://www.empowereddoctor.com/doctor_index_713.html
http://www.westchesteroncology.com/liu_bio.html
剽窃者是来自 - Shanxi Med University
****************************
Dear Friends and colleagues:
We all have heard about fraud and plagiarism, particularly from China, but
you have to see it to believe.
The past three days have been the most difficult and furious time for me in
the three years serving as the Editor-in-chief of JHO, and in my career as a
scientist. I wish to share this experience with you, and hope you will
never have to deal with this.
A manuscript was submitted to JHO three days ago from Shanxi Med University
affiliated hospital. I took a quick look, and the data are beautiful, the
languages need works. I was very excited, thinking this may be the best
paper so far submitted to JHO. I wanted to have a careful review of the
paper, therefore contacted experts in the field, and not using the reviewers
authors requested. To my surprise, the first reviewer returned a review
immediately, and informed me that the data of the manuscript were 100%
pirated from her publication in Blood in 2007. I immediately confirmed the
fact, and was appalled by the flagrant plagiarism ( the blood paper and the
submitted figures attached). I could never imagine that anybody would or
would dare to do this.
What is more saddening and terrifying is that the same group has done
exactly the same thing and already published a paper in Medical Oncology in
feb 2011 by pirating another Blood paper published in 2008.
I hope our professor friends and colleagues educate your staff and hope this
will never happen to any of us.
Regards,
Delong
---------------------------------------
【翻译】
--这封信的中文大意是这样的（感谢“逃”站友友情提供）
ladies and 乡亲们
都说来自中国的造假和剽窃非常牛Ｘ，这次哥算是开了眼了。
作为一个科学工匠和xxx杂志的主编，过去的3天让我如坐针毡。我希望这样操蛋的事情不会发生在你们身上。
事情酱紫滴：
我们收到一篇来自xx医科大学附属医院的稿件。匆匆看完稿件，哥当时就惊了！我知道这可能是我们xxx杂志自创刊以来收到最牛Ｘ的稿件，数据完美，堪称美文。
为了不暴敛天物，哥特意替该文找一个该领域的带头大姐来审稿，而没有使用作者自己推荐的审稿人。
带头大姐不负我所托，以迅雷不及掩耳盗玲之势给我反馈了审稿意见，我以为她一定像我一样为文章的完美而喝彩。
带头大姐是这样说的：这篇文章100%（对不是99.99%）抄袭了我在2007年发表在学霸级期刊ＢＬＯＯＤ上的文章。
对比了blood上的文章和投稿文章，哥崩溃了。
令人更加绝望的是，这还不是他们一次干这样的事情，同一研究小组，在我们xxx杂志2011年2月发表的一篇文章，也copy至2008年发表在blood上的一篇文章。（你们真是对blood情有独钟啊）
哥再也不相信爱情了！
人肉:
线索 1 - 来自 Shanxi - 山西, 不是 "陕西", 陕西的拼音是 Shaanxi;
线索 2 - 被抄袭的内容是围绕 - Notch1;
线索 3 - 依据 Dr Liu, Delong 信中的一句话:
What is more saddening and terrifying is that the same group has done exactly the same thing and already published a paper in Medical Oncology in Feb 2011 by pirating another Blood paper published in 2008.
Now, 回溯 "Medical Oncology in Feb 2011", 这堆 "肉" 是:
Chen Liu, Jianmin Kang, Zhenhua Qiao, Linhua Yang ( 杨林花,YANG Lin-hua -山西医科大学第二附属医院血液科).
C. Liu (&) Department of Hematology, The First Affiliated Hospital ofShanxi Medical University, 030001 Taiyuan, Shanxi,People’s Republic of Chinae-mail: andorra_ieg@163.com
J. Kang Z. Qiao L. Yang Department of Hematology, The Second Affiliated Hospital o fShanxi Medical University, 030001 Taiyuan, Shanxi,People’s Republic of China
这就是 Dr. Liu 在信中提及的, 在今年二月份的 Med Oncol 上发的另一篇 "抄文" ...
它也是出自: 山西医学院, 第一附属医院 和 第二附属医院, 血液科的同一伙人 !!! |
#AI工具#
发表于 2011-6-28 08:53
发表于 2011-6-28 09:12
发表于 2011-7-2 08:15